Smuttynose Island Murders
  • Home
  • The Book
    • Mystery on the Isles of Shoals
    • Reviews
    • Media Coverage
    • The Author
    • Author Appearances
    • Smuttynose Archaeology & History
    • Book Club Questions
  • The Story
    • Background
    • Moonlight Murders
    • Capture
    • Wagner's Trial
    • On the Gallows
  • The People
    • The Victims
    • The Hontvets
    • The Killer
    • Celia Thaxter
    • Cops & Lawyers
    • Key witnesses
  • The Places
    • The Isles of Shoals
    • Smuttynose Island
    • The Hontvet House
    • The Oceanic Hotel
    • Appledore Hotel
    • Portsmouth, NH
    • Alfred, Maine
    • Thomaston Prison
  • Fact Vs Fiction
    • Weught of Water (Novel)
    • Weight of Water (Movie)
    • The Case Against Wagner
    • Conspiracy Theories
  • Blog
    • Why John Hontvet Had to Wait for the Bait
    • The Couch the Killer Did Not Sleep On
    • Smuttynose Murder House is No Longer Standing
    • I Rowed to the Isles of Shoals
    • The Karl Thaxter Theory is Hogwash

Thomaston Prison, Maine

Picture

Thomaston inspired the Shawshank Redemption

Sentenced to death by hanging, Louis Wagner made a daring escape from Alfred Prison, but was soon recaptured and delivered to the Maine state prison at Thomaston. Infamous for its early cruel conditions, Thomaston had originally housed its prisoners in deep holes and worked them at hard labor in a rock quarry. But by 1873, Thomaston was a modern facility where prisoners worked in a variety of occupations from making shoes to carriages. Wagner befriended another ax murderer named John True Gordon, and the two men became model prisoners. During a year and a half on death row, Wagner's attorney Rufus Tapley worked tirelessly to prevent the execution. Maine was on the verge of abolishing capital punishment. Wagner carried his Bible, professed to be reborn, and proclaimed that, "God won't kill an innocent man." The facility at Thomaston was an inspiration for a Stephen King story that was adapted into the film "Shawshank Redemption." The Thomaston prison has since been razed and replaced by a 21st century supermax prison in a neighboring town, but the popular prison gift shop still attracts vacationing tourists. (Photo courtesy of J. Dennis Robinson collection)
Picture