Smuttynose Island Murders
  • Home
  • The Book
    • Mystery on the Isles of Shoals
    • Reviews
    • Media Coverage
    • The Author
    • Author Appearances
    • Smuttynose Archaeology & History
    • Book Club Questions
  • The Story
    • Background
    • Moonlight Murders
    • Capture
    • Wagner's Trial
    • On the Gallows
  • The People
    • The Victims
    • The Hontvets
    • The Killer
    • Celia Thaxter
    • Cops & Lawyers
    • Key witnesses
  • The Places
    • The Isles of Shoals
    • Smuttynose Island
    • The Hontvet House
    • The Oceanic Hotel
    • Appledore Hotel
    • Portsmouth, NH
    • Alfred, Maine
    • Thomaston Prison
  • Fact Vs Fiction
    • Weught of Water (Novel)
    • Weight of Water (Movie)
    • The Case Against Wagner
    • Conspiracy Theories
  • Blog
    • Why John Hontvet Had to Wait for the Bait
    • The Couch the Killer Did Not Sleep On
    • Smuttynose Murder House is No Longer Standing
    • I Rowed to the Isles of Shoals
    • The Karl Thaxter Theory is Hogwash

Smuttynose Island, Maine

Picture

A rocky 27-acre island seven miles from the mainland

At 27-acres, Smuttynose Island is the third largest of the nine islands at the Isles of Shoals. Located just inside the state border of Maine the rocky island is only 30 feet at its highest point. Once a major colonial American  fishing station, Smuttynose is no longer occupied except for summer and fall stewards who greet visitors in season. A new welcome sign and map are available to visitors who are required to sign in and ut when visiting (contributions accepted.) There is no direct transportation to the island and visitors arrive by boat in the small Haley's Cove that empties twice daily.  Thomas Laighton bought the island from the Haley family in 1839 and operated a summer hotel there briefly in the early 1840s. The first significant Shoals hotel, The Mid-Ocean House was located here from the early 1800s. All but two of the dozen island buildings are gone. The island is privately owned and there are no public facilities available. In season stewards maintain a rocky walking trail that leads to the uninhabited part of the island which is a Maine state bird sanctuary. (Photo by J. Dennis Robinson) 
Picture