Smuttynose Island Murders
  • Home
  • The Book
    • Mystery on the Isles of Shoals
    • Reviews
    • Media Coverage
    • The Author
    • Author Appearances
    • Smuttynose Archaeology & History
    • Book Club Questions
  • The Story
    • Background
    • Moonlight Murders
    • Capture
    • Wagner's Trial
    • On the Gallows
  • The People
    • The Victims
    • The Hontvets
    • The Killer
    • Celia Thaxter
    • Cops & Lawyers
    • Key witnesses
  • The Places
    • The Isles of Shoals
    • Smuttynose Island
    • The Hontvet House
    • The Oceanic Hotel
    • Appledore Hotel
    • Portsmouth, NH
    • Alfred, Maine
    • Thomaston Prison
  • Fact Vs Fiction
    • Weught of Water (Novel)
    • Weight of Water (Movie)
    • The Case Against Wagner
    • Conspiracy Theories
  • Blog
    • Why John Hontvet Had to Wait for the Bait
    • The Couch the Killer Did Not Sleep On
    • Smuttynose Murder House is No Longer Standing
    • I Rowed to the Isles of Shoals
    • The Karl Thaxter Theory is Hogwash

Trial of the Century 

Picture

Americans hung on every word in the summer of 1873

Twice attacked by lynch mobs in Portsmouth, NH, Louis Wagner, already known as the "Smuttynose Murderer," was put on trial in York County in the sleepy rural town of Alfred, Maine. Prosecutor's lined up a "hailstorm of evidence" in a circumstantial case featuring over 40 witnesses. With little more than Wagner's shaky alibi, defense attorneys argued, without success, that Smuttynose Island was not in the jurisdiction of York County, and attempted to move the trial.  Farmers left their fields for nine days and dozens of young ladies packed lunches in order to view the handsome prisoner in the packed courtroom. A published transcript gives us a fairly accurate account of the trial that included testimony from police, a Boston prostitute, local fishermen, a blood analysis expert, the husband of one of the murdered women, and Maren Hontvet, the surviving victim.  The trial lasted nine days.  
Picture